With what is going on in the world it is hard to hear the poetry, to take the time for its lessons of humanity, for art’s meaning in our short lives. I thought of doing a selection of short poems. Writing, though, has its way of coming on, pushing through like a birth that cannot be denied. I feel for the people caught up in war, famine, and hopelessness around the world. My heart goes out to both Israelis and Palestinians, and to hope for a change in heart for those infused with dogma and hatred, and to the valiant Ukrainians and closed-off-from-information Russians. I think of where I get the news, reminding myself to look further, read more, communicate more. At the end of this blog, I am adding some of my thoughts.
Different takes on the world as it is today. Some hopeful.
Gate A-4, by Naomi Shihab Nye
and
Mimesis
by Fady Joudah
My daughter
wouldn’t hurt a spider
That had nested
Between her bicycle handles
For two weeks
She waited
Until it left of its own accord
If you tear down the web I said
It will simply know
This isn’t a place to call home
And you’d get to go biking
She said that’s how others
Become refugees isn’t it?
From Alight
Island
by Langston Hughes
Wave of sorrow,
Do not drown me now:
I see the island
Still ahead somehow.
I see the island
And its sands are fair:
Wave of sorrow,
Take me there.
Aharon Shabtai is a famous Jewish poet. His poem, “Lotem Abdel Shafi”, includes the lines:
My heart goes out with love to those beyond the fence;
only toward them can one really advance, that is, make progress.
My friend Richard Spiegel wrote this after the October 7 attack.
Haven’t turned
on the radio yet today.
Staying away from the news.
Everything changes
moment by moment.
Tumbling through
unbearable lost bearings
arms reaching out
swinging slapping
bruising bodies
where is an embrace?
In the distance
rumors of mountains
while here
shadows cast
by homes
along streets
lined with trees.
Counting
steps and breaths.
What counts?
Thoughts on Israel and Palestine October 2023
What does an Israeli ground invasion accomplish now? I don’t believe a military solution exists for Israel. It’s a propaganda war. Palestinian and Israeli spokesmen and women are spinning one-sided stories of victimization. Neither side admits any responsibility for the current situation.
Right now the narrative is that the U.S. and President Biden fully support the Israeli war machine. Listening to Biden’s speech I hear him advising caution, thinking of long-term goals, putting the hostages’ safety first, providing humanitarian aid, and following the rules of war, that is, trying to minimize civilian casualties. Palestinians wanted more sympathy for their plight. This is because we are all human. We need to be recognized as having meaningful lives, lives that are important as any other lives.
The cycle is the same every time, and with so much distrust the truth about specific events doesn’t matter, which means people can fabricate narratives that support their side.
The cycle. Every time the peace process was making progress, an attack by a suicide bomber or gunman would be carried out against Israelis by a Palestinian extremist who rejected the existence of the state of Israel and therefore a two-state solution. Wouldn’t that have been calculated in after the first several times? Yes, there’s going to be an attack by someone who doesn’t want peace and co-existence between the two, and we know that, and when it happens we will not be deterred, we’ll continue the peace negotiations. But no, it worked every time. And it continued to be a tool of those who opposed peace in the region.
Narratives. How easy it is to descend into conspiracy theories. What if? Netanyahu and his right-wing government knew they were losing popularity, and on hearing there might be an attack, made sure there was minimal security along the Gaza border. They thought the attack wouldn’t be that bad. Then they could rally people around them again. The attack turned out to be horrific. But that only plays even more into Netanyahu’s hands. A country’s not going to change presidents during wartime, right? Rather than hold him and his government and the military leaders accountable, Israeli citizens appear to support a full-scale response. And we hear the war may last ten years!
Truth. There are alternatives to bombing and a ground war. Strengthening the border, beefing up security, infiltrating Hamas, stopping the flow of money and arms, judicious use of special forces, changes in policy, diplomacy and public relations might be a better course.
The hospital attack happened just before Biden was to meet with other leaders in the region. Who benefits from this attack? Hamas or another jihadist group, since they do not want peace with Israel. Their stated purpose is to end the state of Israel. Another possibility, the hard right Israeli government which thrives off conflict with Palestinians. Biden was suggesting changes in direction that Netanyahu and his followers oppose, such as working with the Palestinian Authority, which means looking at root causes, and showing support for Arab leaders in the region.
When Yasser Arafat changed from violence to diplomacy, Israeli leaders worked to de-legitimize him, saying, once a terrorist, always a terrorist. They undermined the PLO’s efforts to seek a peaceful resolution. Arafat came close to succeeding when President Clinton tried to broker a deal with Israel, but he could not accept the two-state solution as presented because it meant Palestinians would be living in two separate areas (West Bank and Gaza), and he knew his people would not accept that.
In the intervening years, Israel has continued to build Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank, an area not granted to them by the original U.N. agreement. President Obama urged Israel to extend its moratorium on further settlements but stopped short of calling them illegal, in a balancing act that has become wearisome for all. Unfortunately, more settlements were built.
The jihadist movement has only grown stronger because of this ongoing conflict. War serves the purpose of Iran and its vision of an Islamic caliphate or allied Islamic states.
Richard writes, Peaceful coexistence is a reality that must be embraced. People do not have to live in constant states of war, or threats of war. But not in a Pax Romana (any state of peace imposed by a strong nation on weaker or defeated nations).
By one-sidedly supporting Israel or the Palestinians, we keep people in their silos, and in endless conflict. Making excuses for either side, justifying the taking of hostages or displacing people from their homes, should never be acceptable. Root causes must include the actions of Israel but also the Islamic jihadist groups (and their sponsors) that harbor among peaceful Arab and other regional citizens and disrupt any attempts at peace.